When will citizen journalism website STOMP clean up its shit?

25 Jun

Mr Patrick Daniel, editor-in-chief of SPH’s English and Malay Newspapers Division, has sent a letter to Mr Tan Ek Kia, the interim chief executive of rail operator SMRT, to apologise for a fake photograph that was published on SPH’s citizen journalism, STOMP. The citizen journalist, STOMPER “wasabi”, alleged that there was a serious safety breach when the train was moving with its door open for at least one stop when she was travelling from Lakeside to City Hall MRT station.

It has now been revealed that the photo was lifted off Twitter and “wasabi” was never on the train and the entire story was fabricated despite making its way to a SPH website, a company that prides itself for responsible reporting.

Image

STOMPER “wasabi” is STOMP content producer!

What is more shocking is that “wasabi” is no citizen journalist but employed by STOMP as a content producer (more like content fabricator)!! Now we really wonder how much of the content on STOMP is produced/fabricated by their own staff? Why doesn’t STOMP inform its readers that the contributor was a staff and tries to make it seem as if all their content are submitted by members of the public? And if they are employed by STOMP/SPH why are they not subjected to the rigours of fact-checking and journalistic ethics? This stinks of mis-representation.

It is apparent that STOMP would approve and publish just about any story that is sensational without any fact checking from its own content producers.

So would the public ever be aware if STOMP decides to slip in a fabricated story, stir it up online and it gets reported in mainstream newspapers as a legitimate story? They are after all all owned by one company!

Such journalistic standards and practices are deplorable and can be easily abused. For the media to act as effective arm of civil society, the media giant that SPH is should be broken up as it controls a definite majority of the entire spectrum (offline and online) of news production in Singapore. Such monopolistic characteristics are prone to spectacular failures in addition to being poor in representing the diversity of society’s views. Besides STOMP, SPH also has a stake in popular portals like Hardwarezone and Asiaone.

Liar, liar pants on fire

STOMPER “wasabi” aka Ms Samantha Francis, would join a long line of rouge journalists who fabricated stories to get ahead in the game. She is not the first and neither will she be the last. There should be mechanism to prevent and deter this in any respectable system. Currently a student at NTU, English Language and Literature, Samantha is due to graduate this year and I hope this would be a rude wake-up call to her as she joins the workforce.

It takes ten lies to cover-up the first lie. To perpetuate her lie that she was at Lakeside MRT station around 10:15pm on a Tuesday night, Samantha even had the cheek to turn up at the station with SMRT staff to verify her story. She gave a description of what she wore and her ez-link card both of which drew a blank with SMRT CCTV and ez-link systems. OMG! How lame…

Image

Samantha Francis in a dress telling her version of the story

Obviously, she is not very apt at lying or she might be serial liar, albeit a very losuy one. STOMP should get better and smarter content fabricators if they want to stay ahead of the competition!! Haha!!

In this instance, fortunately, the story was verifiable as there were details, time, location and an organisation (i.e. SMRT) which had its own interests to make things right. Imagine if some “citizen journalist” was to submit some unverifiable story like two man fighting at somewhere in Toa Payoh and one spoke with an heavy India Indian accent, get their friends to punch it up while another filmed it.

Ironically, Samantha wrote an article titled “10 ways to become a public nuisance” back in Feb for local entertainment website Fever Avenue, never thinking that she will be the 11th.

Advertisements

11 Responses to “When will citizen journalism website STOMP clean up its shit?”

  1. KD Tan June 25, 2012 at 12:20 pm #

    Samantha Ann Francis… is she from the land where lying and fabricating lies is a national past-time, ie. Philippines?

    • Xu Si Han June 25, 2012 at 2:34 pm #

      So apparently there is no such thing as “Eurasians” in Singapore.

  2. Alamak June 25, 2012 at 1:11 pm #

    I am always irked by the contents in the STOMP and feel that many of them are parading around playing moral police for the most minutiae details and small matters. Right now, I wonder if many of the sensational stories that were reported were actually “staged” by their own friends or actors to create content for content sake.

    Take down the STOMPERS!!

  3. Joshua June 25, 2012 at 1:57 pm #

    What are “rouge” journalists I wonder? Are they a new breed of reporters dedicated to cosmetics and shoddy journalism? This long line seems to be quite well-disguised then, as I’ve personally never seen or heard of them before. It seems that their make-up certainly befits their name then. What a revelation. Accolades should be heaped upon this, for revealing the existence of such a frightening, secret order of yellow journalism and red lipstick. Far more shocking than a woman whose job was to be a e-tabloid staff member and her unsurprising lack of journalistic integrity.

    Just kidding. May want to tone down the accusatory tones a little; makes one wonder if there’s a personal stake in this rather than ethical or professional. Otherwise very well-written.

  4. Pauline S June 25, 2012 at 3:32 pm #

    This is hilarious.

    http://everythingalsocomplain.com/2012/06/23/the-case-of-the-open-mrt-train-door/

  5. Repost on SgHardtruth June 25, 2012 at 4:49 pm #

    Reblogged this on SG Hard Truth.

  6. jeff June 25, 2012 at 11:56 pm #

    It’s disgraceful that people are again dragging foreigners into the issue blasting Samantha as a Pinoy. Local or foreign has nothing to do with this.

  7. Fren of Sam June 26, 2012 at 8:52 am #

    Samantha has learnt her lesson and she is really remorseful. She didn’t expect her actions would result in such serious repercussions. It was silly on her part but she meant no malice. Please do give her a chance. Tks.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Daily SG: 25 June 2012 | The Singapore Daily - June 25, 2012

    […] The Cartoon Press) Citizen Journalism? – Unbranded Bread n Butter: When will citizen journalism website STOMP clean up its shit? – Bertha Harian: Trust no one? – DKSG: Time for STOMP to come clean – Everything Also Complain: The […]

  2. Editor-in-chief apologises to SMRT over Stomp picture. And Mr Low Thia Khiang says the MSM is biased… « SG Hard Truth - June 25, 2012

    […] BreadnButter –   When will citizen journalism website STOMP clean up its shit? Share this:TwitterFacebookEmailLike this:LikeBe the first to like this. This entry was posted […]

  3. Zoroukah – When will citizen journalism website STOMP clean up its mess? - June 27, 2012

    […] This article first appeared on Unbranded BreadnButter’s blog. […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: